Showing posts with label economic forecasts. Show all posts
Showing posts with label economic forecasts. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 24, 2015

24/11/15: Captured Economics and the Victim State


Per Simon Wren-Lewis: “…Perhaps the problem at the heart of the Eurozone is that economic policy advice in Germany has been effectively captured by employers' interests, and perhaps the interests of banks in particular.” (source here)

For one caveat: economics as profession has been largely captured by the state.

The European states are, of course, themselves have been captured by corporatist interests, including (but not limited to) those of big businesses and banks. One can make a similar argument about other (non-European) states too. Which makes the capture of economists by business only a part of that more corroded chain, and not an exclusive part. Otherwise, how can one explain that it is State-employed economists and State-aligned economists (with State boards positions and State research contracts) that so vocally defend the very same corporate welfare that Simon Wren-Lewis seems to correctly worry about?

My view on the subject was covered here: http://trueeconomics.blogspot.ie/2015/10/301015-why-economists-failed-whats-up.html.

In simple terms, enough whitewashing the State as a victim of business interests - instead, time to see the State as a willing participant in a corporatist system that allows capture of policy development and implementation mechanisms and institutions by vested interests that define the State.


Friday, October 30, 2015

30/10/15: Why Economists Failed & What's Up With Irish Banking Reforms?..


Earlier this week I gave a small presentation to a group of academics and researchers from Holland on two topics:

  1. Why majority of economists did not foresee the Global Financial Crisis? and
  2. What is the state of play with Irish banking sector reforms?
Here are my slides from the talk:
















Tuesday, October 14, 2014

14/10/2014: Budget 2015: Economic Forecasts a Bit Optimistic

Here's my take on economic side of the Budget 2015 projections:

Gross current expenditure for 2015 will be just over €50 billion. This figure represents an increase of €429 million over the 2014 Revised Estimates. Note: in H1 2014, Government spent EUR35.567 billion which is EUR1.255 billion more than in the same period 2013. As unemployment fell, social benefits rose from EUR13.823 billion to EUR14.016 billion. General Government Deficit has fallen only EUR307 million y/y in H1 2014. These numbers are not consistent with strong economy or strong fiscal performance. Meanwhile, the state took out of the economy EUR1.893 billion more in taxes and social contributions in H1 2014 compared to H1 2013. Where did this increase of funding go?

Government deficit target for 2015 is 2.7% of GDP under ESA 2010 classification. Which means that going back to Troika programmes-comparable measure (ESA 1995 classification), the target deficit is closer to 3.2% of GDP. This is ahead of 3% target and shows how much debt we owe not to smart management of resources, but to accounting rules changes.

Here's a set of economic puzzles courtesy of the Department of Finance:

Real growth is slowing down from 2014 levels, but employment generation is rising. A puzzle. Especially as domestic demand is expected to grow at same rate in 2015 and growth rate is expected to fall in years after.

As compared against other organisations forecasts:

Added puzzle: IMF projections for Irish economy real GDP growth are: 2015 3.045% - full 0.85 percentage points lower than DofF, 2016: 2.538% which is full 0.87 percentage points below DofF, in 2017 : 2.649% or 0.75 percentage points below DofF… and so on.

And another kicker in the teeth… the promise of fiscal rectitude and 'no going back to boom-and-bust cycles':

All of the above is rather academic, since the Department of Finance refuses to forecast Gross Voted Current expenditure of the Exchequer beyond 2015, setting all of it at EUR50.075 billion for each year 2015-2018. Which means the estimated effects on deficit and on borrowing are based on assuming zero growth in spending and continued growth in tax revenues. Happy times roll, even though Haddington Road agreement is about to expire.

Still, as you can see, debt/GDP ratio is expected to fall, courtesy of higher GDP, including the new classification effects that came into force this year. But debt itself is not expected to fall. Instead, from EUR 203.2 billion, Government debt is expected to rise to EUR 215 billion in 2017 and basically stay there in 2018.

So on the balance: a bit too much optimism, especially past 2015. Not enough risk cushion. May the numbers turn out this well in reality...